Editorial: Being intoxicated must not be allowed to stand as a viable defence in criminal cases

Victim has permanent physical damage after an attack by ‘nice guy’ out of control on magic mushrooms

Alberta Judge Michele Hollins delivered a truly horrifying court decision this week, one that we feel must go to the Supreme Court of Canada, or risk setting back Canadian law by decades.

The case is pretty straightforward, and so, one would have thought, would be a guilty verdict. Instead, Matthew Brown got an absolute gift of an acquittal that leaves us afraid for the future of justice in this country.

RELATED: Alberta man who took magic mushrooms found not guilty of assaulting professor

Brown, now 29, was a student at Mount Royal University when he drank and got high one night on magic mushrooms, voluntarily, and proceeded to strip naked, break into professor Janet Hamnett’s home, and violently beat her with a broom handle until she was able to escape.

His defence? He was too high to be held responsible for his actions. And oh, he’s actually a really nice guy and he’s really sorry. And he hadn’t had a bad reaction when he did magic mushrooms before.

In what world is this man acquitted? Hamnett has permanent physical damage to one hand from the attack, not to mention the psychological trauma.

What if he’d killed her? Or raped her? Or cut off an appendage? Would he still have been acquitted, because being high made it not his fault?

The bottom line is that he chose to become so intoxicated, and he’s responsible for what he did while in that state. Legal decisions have reflected this view in the past. We don’t let drunk drivers who kill someone off the hook because they were drunk behind the wheel. In fact, that’s an aggravating factor, not the opposite.

Our justice system cannot start allowing criminals to get away with their crimes as long as they’re high or drunk enough. It would lead to anarchy, and a country we don’t want to live in. We’d argue there’s clearly an element of white, middle class privilege happening here as well. We cannot imagine such a verdict for a First Nations man, or a black man, or an immigrant. Or a homeless drug addict. Someone who’s not the captain of a hockey team.

This case must be appealed, all the way to Canada’s top court if necessary. Intoxication is not a defence.


Just Posted

Nanaimo’s Harmac mill works to fill doubled pulp order for medical masks and gowns

Mill’s president says extra cleaning in place and workers are social distancing

Life mimics art for Island students who performed play about Spanish flu pandemic

Performing arts students see parallels between story from Unity 1918 and current health crisis

Sex workers face new risks during COVID-19 pandemic

‘Desperation has kicked in’ for vulnerable, undocumented workers unable to access help

Food safety a good practice amid COVID-19 concerns

BC Centre for Disease Control offers useful food safe information for households

Mitchell’s Musings: Parking tickets in a pandemic

Despite COVID-19 crisis, paid parking police is still going to get you

VIDEO: How doctors in Canada will decide who lives and dies if pandemic worsens

Officials in several provinces have been developing guides so that doctors don’t feel alone

‘Small python’ found in vacant Cook Street apartment

Snake taken to CRD Animal Shelter to be claimed

COVID-19: Postponed surgeries will be done, B.C. health minister says

Contract with private surgical clinic to help clear backlog

Nanaimo man arrested after allegedly setting house fire

Firefighters arrived to find mobile home ablaze on Barnes Road in Cedar on Thursday

Saanich councillor named one of Canada’s Top 25 Environmentalists Under 25

Coun. Ned Taylor, three other young environmentalists from Greater Victoria on the list

Most Read