Demonstrators walk a flock of sheep through the streets as part of a protest against Brexit, in central London, Thursday, Aug. 15, 2019. Protestors are walking sheep past government buildings as part of ‘Farmers for a People’s Vote’ to highlight the risk Brexit presents to livestock. (AP Photo/Vudi Xhymshiti)

Do surveys and referendums work for our democracy?

Direct democracy in the form of surveys and referendum is at odds with western liberal democracy

In western liberal democracies, political representatives are elected on a mandate that is meant to reflect the will of the people. They are entrusted to make decisions on behalf of their constituents.

Despite the system, governments have relied increasingly on surveys and referendums to make decisions.

The B.C. government recently put out a survey asking what British Columbians thought about daylight savings time. Unsurprisingly, 93 percent of respondents wanted to do away with the practice. The cost of that survey was $31,000 — a drop in the bucket of the Ministry of Attorney General’s annual operating budget. That cost includes the entire survey, the data analysis, and the preparation of a report on the survey data.

RELATED: More than 90% of British Columbians want permanent daylight time

Still, $31,000 to find out something that people have said for decades is a bit much.

At their most altruistic, surveys show that governments are willing to listen to their constituents. The trouble of them is that surveys are at odds with the structure of our political system.

A prime example of the dangers of survey and referendum is the ongoing Brexit saga. The decision to leave the European Union should have been made by qualified elected representatives based on factual evidence and expert advice. Instead, it was decided by a slim 52 percent majority of the public. And the cherry on top — the referendum cost 129 million pounds, ($210.4 million CAD).

Britain is now facing potential food and medicine shortages — and economic disaster — if a no-deal Brexit occurs.

An example closer to home is the B.C. government’s 2018 referendum on electoral reform, which had a total budget of $14.5 million, and 2011’s HST referendum that had a budget of $8 million. In the first case, B.C. residents were not given a clear alternative to the first past the post system, and electoral reform was defeated by the largest margin of all three attempts to change the system.

RELATED: B.C. referendum rejects proportional representation

The HST referendum was another policy decision that should have been made by experts, but was left to the public to decide.

When it comes to democracy, there can be rule by an elected body of representatives, or direct democracy where the public makes policy decisions. In an ideal world, there would be both. However, in the world as it is today, there needs to be a clear distinction between the two.

If elected representatives choose to rely on surveys, referendums, and other forms of direct democracy to make decisions, then what is the point of having an elected assembly at all?

Just Posted

Commercial fisheries off-loading business booming in Port Hardy

Off-loading facilities pack, ice, and load in totes the fish that are caught by commercial fishermen

Four days of mediation fail to break four-month strike in the woods

Steelworkers union says Western Forest Products refuses to budge from ‘unreasonable concessions’

Vancouver Island firefighters showcased on Discovery Channel

Second season of Hellfire Heroes premieres Oct. 22

Birders flocking to Greater Victoria after rare warbler sighting

Tiny bird draws big audience to Panama Flats

Guilty verdict for man accused of setting fire to his Esquimalt rental property

Wei Li was arrested at airport with burns to face and hands

In the news: Liberals eke out a win, but will need NDP, Green support to pass bills

Conservatives say they are ready if Trudeau should falter

Oak Bay to complete LED switchover of 1,506 street lamps

Electricians to install final 356 steet lamps

Second young woman dies after rollover crash near Williams Lake

‘Someone’s going to get her heart, which is awesome, because she has the best heart in the world’

Google searches for ‘how to vote’ surge on Election Day

Interest spikes despite social media campaign by Elections Canada

Alberta man pleads guilty, fined for hunting without a licence in North Island

It’s the responsibility of each hunter or angler to know whether they are considered a B.C. Resident.

Raiders to face Rebels in football playoffs

Island football squads on a collision course for the playoffs

Report suggests new BC Ferries terminal near YVR

Metro Vancouver currently has two ferry terminals at northern and southern reaches

Alcohol a possible factor in crash that killed 17-year-old girl near Williams Lake

A pickup truck left the road and rolled over on Highway 20 on the weekend

B.C. woman must pay $1,000 after unleashed dog bites another

Owner should never have left Bibi unattended, tribunal member wrote

Most Read