Vancouver Island school superintendent says ranking ‘does more harm than good’

Elementary schools ranked annually by Fraser Institute

The controversial Fraser Institute ranking of B.C. elementary schools is back and so are its critics.

The report card ranks 955 public and private elementary schools based on 10 academic indicators that are derived from the province-wide Foundation Skills Assessment results, according to a new release issued Thursday.

School District 69 (Qualicum) interim superintendent of schools Keven Elder said he believes that although the Fraser Institute “has a right to do what they are doing, their work does more harm than good.”

He said the data, methods and algorithms the institute uses paint a very narrow picture.

“They fail to capture what truly counts as success in a modern education system, that being a wide range of experiences in intellectual development, social-emotional learning, Indigenous ways of knowing, arts, physical literacy, career explorations, community service, supports for vulnerable learners and so much more,” Elder said. “Those successes are experienced by our students every day. Our students and parents are getting what they simply would not get in schools that top the rankings.”

Elder said he believes that some of the schools from around the province that are at the bottom of the rankings are doing some of the “best work in service to children whose life experiences are challenging.”

“Being at the bottom of a narrow-measured list does them far more harm than good,” he said. “As for our community, if people want to know how schools are doing, visit them, look at our planning documents and see our school websites. Engage with schools, and with our outstanding teaching, support and administrative staff, every chance you get.

“Our doors are open; come in and see what really creates student success, and what leads our learners toward graduating with dignity, purpose and options.”

The complete list of school rankings can be found here.

— With files from Black Press

Just Posted

Discovery Island wolf continues to thrive

The wolf, known as ‘Takaya’, has lived on the island for seven years

Early indications say allergy season could be milder this spring

The Aerobiology Lab collects pollen samples from across Canada to help make predictions

EDITORIAL: Housing is one of our basic needs

We all need food, clothing and shelter first

BIG READ: The two sides of the Strait of Georgia roe herring fishery

The case for the Strait of Georgia roe herring fishery Comox fisherman,… Continue reading

Victoria HarbourCats give away funeral to lucky fan

Just in case you die of excitment, all the bases are covered

After mosque attacks, New Zealand bans ‘military-style’ guns

The gunman killed 50 in a Christchurch mosque

ICBC shifts to Alberta model, with higher premiums, private insurers say

Minor injury cap, court restrictions take effect April 1 in B.C.

Trans woman hopes funding cut will send message to B.C. rape crisis group

Rape Relief does not turn transgender women away and often connects them to other services, group says

UPDATED: Missing Victoria man found dead in Port Renfrew

Police continuing investigation, death not considered suspicious

B.C. sees fourth straight day of record-breaking warmth

Bob Marley said it best: The sun is shining and the weather is sweet

Overturned vessels, simulated smoke expected in Victoria harbour for Coast Guard exercise

Coast Guard and other first responders will be on the water from 1 - 4 p.m. Thursday

Okanagan man, Yorkshire terrier chased by coyote

Animal sightings have been reported around West Kelowna and the Central Okanagan

Scientists disembark in Nanaimo after international expedition probes Pacific salmon

Canadian, American, Russian, Korean and Japanese scientists survey salmon in Gulf of Alaska

Most Read