250 Terminal Ave. (NEWS BULLETIN file photo)

Nanaimo supportive housing isn’t subject to zoning bylaws, says Supreme Court

Terminal Avenue neighbour forced to pay defendants’ legal costs after unsuccessful court challenge

A supportive housing complex in Nanaimo set up by the province last fall didn’t need to be built according to city zoning bylaws, the Supreme Court of B.C. has ruled.

Janet Buechler, on behalf of neighbours of Newcastle Place on Terminal Avenue, brought to court B.C. Housing, the Provincial Rental Housing Corporation, Island Crisis Care Society and the City of Nanaimo this year, arguing that the supportive housing complex at 250 Terminal Ave. is subject to city zoning regulations.

The province set up supportive housing at Terminal Avenue and Labieux Road in the fall of 2018 to help accommodate people experiencing homelessness who had been living at Discontent City encampment at 1 Port Drive.

“The city and the provincial government agents understood that compliance with municipal zoning bylaws would not be possible,” wrote Supreme Court Justice Amy Francis in her decision.

RELATED: Terminal Ave supportive housing lawsuit goes before B.C. Supreme Court in Nanaimo

The court decision included a letter to the municipality from B.C. Housing’s director of regional development on Vancouver Island, Malcolm McNaughton, advising that B.C. Housing would be “exercising paramountcy” at 250 Terminal Ave. and 2020 Labieux Rd. Francis wrote that McNaughton’s testimony explained that B.C. Housing was advising of its intention to rely on a section of the Interpretation Act “to bypass the city’s zoning and permitting process.”

The court found that B.C. Housing “remains an active participant in the management, funding and operation of Newcastle Place” and that the facility is a Crown asset “to be used for a social purpose that will further provincial objectives.” Francis decided that even if Island Crisis Care Society was considered the user of the land, it would be protected under the Interpretation Act from compliance with municipal zoning bylaws.

The court ruled that the plaintiff, unsuccessful in her claim, must pay the legal costs of the defendants.

RELATED: Resident files civil claim against Newcastle Place groups

RELATED: Council concerned about Terminal Avenue project



editor@nanaimobulletin.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Just Posted

Victoria resident accuses BC Transit of repeated discrimination since transitioning to a wheelchair

Daniel Sands says they are often not allowed on buses, even when there is room

Residents concerned land sale could threaten south Island water supply

Sale will allow for the subdivision and development of forestry lands in Shirley, west of Sooke

Island author talks about his book ‘The Blue Haired Girl’

Adam Hayes sat down with North Island Gazette Editor Tyson Whitney for an interview about the book.

Kwigwatsi Studio a labour of love for Comox Valley couple

The studio is at 3250 Comox Road and overlooks the Bighouse and K’omoks First Nation Band Office.

Island filmmaker receives funds to produce web series pilot

Chukwumuobi Obasi was awarded the funds through Telus Storyhive’s Web Series Edition

Apartment residents evacuated due to fire near downtown Nanaimo

Nanaimo Fire Rescue responded to structure fire on Prideaux Street Saturday afternoon

Pacioretty scores 2, Golden Knights top Canucks 6-3

Vegas goalie Fleury gets win No. 452

Woman arrested after police pursuit, alleged abduction at Island elementary school

Two police officers were injured and one police vehicle damaged

Nanaimo Fire Rescue lauds boys after rescue from cliffs

Nanaimo firefighters responded to call near Departure Bay Road Saturday afternoon

Workers at auto dealerships in Nanaimo and Victoria set up picket lines

Sixty GAIN Group detailers, technicians, service advisors went on strike Friday

Apartment residents evacuated due to fire near downtown Nanaimo

Nanaimo Fire Rescue responded to structure fire on Prideaux Street Saturday afternoon

Smoke from motorhome fire seen all over Port Alberni

Space heater left inside thought to be cause of fire

Palestinians in Bethlehem look beyond religious tourism

BETHLEHEM, Palestinian Territory — For decades, the people of Bethlehem have watched… Continue reading

Students coming up with signature VIU chocolate

Blind taste testing this week part of chocolate recipe competition

Most Read