Police executed a search warrant at a residence on Nicol Street in September 2017 in relation to a murder investigation. John Albert Buchanan was charged with second-degree murder. (News Bulletin file)

Police executed a search warrant at a residence on Nicol Street in September 2017 in relation to a murder investigation. John Albert Buchanan was charged with second-degree murder. (News Bulletin file)

Murder trial begins in case of man who was beaten and died in Nanaimo’s south end

John Albert Buchanan charged with second-degree murder after 2017 incident on Nicol Street

The trial has begun for a man facing a second-degree murder charge in the 2017 death of a man at a south Nanaimo apartment.

John Albert Buchanan was arrested on Sept. 13, 2017 after Richard Steven Sitar was found dead at Harbour View Manor on Nicol Street two days previous. Buchanan’s trial began this morning, Oct. 19, at B.C. Supreme Court in Nanaimo.

Leanne Mascolo, co-Crown counsel, told Judge Robin Baird that Buchanan has given numerous versions of what happened the day of the murder, which she said are false, not supported by other evidence and intentionally fabricated.

Sitar, a known drug user who also dealt with stolen property, died from multiple blunt force trauma to his head, said Mascolo. The murder scene saw significant amounts of blood from the wounds and in a splattered pattern and it appeared Sitar received the wounds while sitting on a couch in his living room.

RELATED: Second-degree murder charge in Nicol Street murder

Buchanan and Sitar knew each other, with the accused often seen at the victim’s apartment, said Mascolo. Surveillance footage showed Buchanan arriving at the apartment at about 6:16 p.m. the night of the murder on a bicycle, wearing a distinctive bright green T-shirt.

The video shows Buchanan entering the building, taking an elevator to Sitar’s second-floor apartment and entering at 6:21 p.m. Mascolo said footage shows Sitar’s wife returning home and trying unsuccessfully to gain entry into the apartment. The door was locked, as she had forgotten her key, and she subsequently left the building. A few minutes later, Buchanan is seen exiting the apartment, down a stairway, carrying bags and items he didn’t have on his arrival.

Sitar’s wife returned 20 minutes later, with a neighbour, and gained access to the apartment, discovering Sitar seriously injured.

Surveillance footage from the Balmoral Hotel on Haliburton Street, where Buchanan went after exiting the apartment, shows the accused stopping beside a dumpster and leaning a covered item against the fence, said Mascolo. He picked up the item took it out of the camera’s view, appearing a few minutes later without the item, she said.

According to a toxicology report, Sitar had high and toxic levels of methamphetamines, methadone and fentanyl in his system, Mascolo told the court.

A search warrant was executed on Sept. 14 for a backyard of a property on 150 Nicol St., where Buchanan had been residing.

The trial is scheduled to run until Nov. 25. Michael Munro is serving as defence counsel and Catherine Hagen is also representing the Crown in the case.



reporter@nanaimobulletin.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Court

Just Posted

Island Health’s acting medical health officer for the central Island says schools are very safe, even after COVID-19 exposure at five schools in Nanaimo-Ladysmith this month. (File photo)
Island Health: Vancouver Island schools are ‘very safe’

Central Island medical health officer answers questions on the heels of recent school exposures

A photograph from July 25, where the Straitwatch team and DFO were out along the eastern shoreline of Vancouver Island to attend to a humpback whale that was reported entangled . (Photo courtesy, Cetus Research and Conservation Society)
Islander launches campaign to help entangled whales

Tristan Ray-Wilks from Quadra Island wants to be “response ready” for humpbacks in distress

In the first nine months of 2020, there have been 23 drug toxicity deaths in North Vancouver Island. Pixabay photo
Vancouver Island’s drug overdose emergency far from over

COVID-19 has exacerbated drug toxicity death rate

Bert Hick of Rising Tide Consultants, specializing in liquor licensing, addresses city council on Nov. 19, 2019. (City of Chilliwack)
Opinion: Your council has a tougher job than you give it credit for

Councillors work hard and for a capricious master

B.C. Special Olympics athlete, Jake Hooper, and his sister Caitlin are concerned about the impact COVID-19 is having on people with intellectual disabilities. (Courtesy of Caitlin Hooper)
Pandemic raises stakes for B.C. residents with intellectual disabilities

Untrained health care workers can jeopardize lives of people with ID

Kyle Charles poses for a photo in Edmonton on Friday, Nov. 20, 2020. Marvel Entertainment, the biggest comic book publisher in the world, hired the 34-year-old First Nations illustrator as one of the artists involved in Marvel Voice: Indigenous Voices #1 in August. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
VIDEO: Indigenous illustrator of new Marvel comic hopes Aboriginal women feel inspired

Kyle Charles says Indigenous women around the world have reached out

This Union Bay beach area shows iron staining at low tide from March 2010. Photo, JET Productions
Commercial marina again proposed for Union Bay

A previous proposal was denied due to sediment contamination

A rendering of Victoria Wonderland, a drive-thru immersive holiday experience coming to the Breakwater District at Ogden Point. (Courtesy of Transcend Victoria)
Immersive, drive-thru holiday light show coming to Victoria

‘Victoria Wonderland’ runs from Dec. 7 to Dec. 31

Juliette Desvaux, left, and gym owner Meaghan Orcutt share a joke during a break in a workout session. (Submitted photo)
Parksville sprinter finds much-needed community support during COVID-19 pandemic

Local gym, former coaches lend a hand with Desvaux’s athletic endeavours

I-Hos Gallery manager Ramona Johnson shows some of the paddles available at the retail outlet. Photo by Terry Farrell
I-Hos Gallery celebrates 25 years of promoting First Nation artwork

K’ómoks First Nation-based outlet has art from all over the country

An Oceana Canada audit of Canadian fish stocks reveals a growing number with critical populations, calling on Fisheries and Oceans Canada to enact existing commitments. (File photo)
B.C.’s declining fisheries the result of poor DFO management: audit

Oceana Canada calls for follow through on government commitments

Most Read