Skip to content

K’ómoks First Nation wins precedent setting case regarding land management

Court case surrounded eviction of tenants who refused to vacate property after termination of lease
13907976_web1_181011-CVR-N-KFNruling

The K’ómoks First Nation has won a landmark case upholding its rights as a property manager.

After a 10-month court battle ended last month, KFN is believed to have become the first Indigenous community to successfully prosecute private criminal charges for trespassing under the KFN’s land code.

According to a KFN media release, the case involved a couple who had their lease terminated in December of 2017. Despite being asked to leave, and being served a letter of trespass issued by the Chief, they remained in the home from that time until Oct. 2. They made no payments to the owner, and have done extensive damage to the home as well as the property, which is owned by the Nation.

“It was extremely frustrating,” said K’omoks Chief Nicole Rempel. “They flat out refused to leave. We contacted the RCMP numerous times. We had meetings at a Chief and Council level with the RCMP, and they refused to uphold the law, because the land code wasn’t a law they were familiar with.”

Because the couple were trespassers under the KFN land code, local RCMP and Crown prosecutors didn’t know how to get involved.

Following a guilty verdict issued on Sept. 25, they were given until the sentencing date of Oct. 2 to remove their belongings and evacuate the home. At sentencing they were given a $1,000 fine each, as well as six months’ probation.

“I’m extremely happy that the provincial court decided that this was something we could uphold,” Rempel said. “Hopefully, we don’t have to go through the court again. Hopefully, the relevant authorities recognize the law and uphold it the way they’re supposed to. This verdict is a great advancement in recognition of first nations laws and a win in our advancement in self-government.”

The KFN Land Code is the result of the First Nations Land Management Act enacted in 1999, which gave First Nations the authority to write their own laws for managing land and resources. However, the ability to create their own laws did not necessarily mean the RCMP would uphold those laws, which led the Nation to apply to the courts to conduct a private criminal prosecution of current tenants, without the usual assistance from police and the Crown.

13907976_web1_181011-CVR-N-KFNruling1
13907976_web1_181011-CVR-N-KFNruling2
13907976_web1_181011-CVR-N-KFNruling3