A North Cowichan/Duncan Mountie has been cleared of excessive force in a Dec. 30 2019 incident. (Citizen file)

A North Cowichan/Duncan Mountie has been cleared of excessive force in a Dec. 30 2019 incident. (Citizen file)

Cowichan Mountie cleared of wrongdoing after woman’s arm broken during arrest

Police were called around 10 p.m. on Dec. 30, 2019 to remove a “severely intoxicated” woman

The Independent Investigations Office of B.C. has cleared a North Cowichan/Duncan RCMP officer of any wrongdoing in the apprehension of a woman under the influence of alcohol on Dec. 30, 2019.

“The purpose of any IIO investigation is to determine whether there are reasonable grounds to believe that an officer, through an action or inaction, may have committed any offence in relation to an incident resulting in serious harm or death,” wrote chief civilian director Ronald J. MacDonald in his decision. “More specifically, the issue to be considered in this case is whether an officer may have used unauthorized or excessive force against the AP (affected person).”

Police were called around 10 p.m. on Dec. 30, 2019 to remove a “severely intoxicated” woman who’d been demanding entry to a home she’d previously agreed not to visit when she’d been drinking.

According to MacDonald’s decision, the woman became belligerent and yelled loudly. In an attempt to handcuff the woman, one officer held one of the woman’s arms and the subject officer held the other as he told her she was being arrested for mischief and causing a disturbance.

The woman “suddenly collapsed to the ground as a ‘dead weight’,” said the report. The woman “flung herself” to the ground and there was a “popping” sound.

“The officers lifted AP by her armpits and helped her to the police vehicle, where she collapsed to the ground again.”

The woman was assessed by paramedics at the detachment before going to the hospital where doctors confirmed she’d broken her left humerus.

“Her blood alcohol concentration, when tested at the hospital, was found to be nearly five times the legal limit for driving,” MacDonald said in the report. “She told investigators that she recalled drinking on the day in question, but had no memory of the incident.”

The IIO determined the officer being accused of excessive force was taking reasonable action.

“They were justified in placing her under arrest and removing her. In those circumstances, handcuffing a detainee before placing her into the police vehicle for transport is normal and proper procedure, to control the individual and ensure the safety of everyone,” the report said. “On the evidence, it is clear that AP became particularly uncooperative at this point, and there is no suggestion that her fall to the ground was anything other than a tactic to thwart the officers’ attempts to escort her away from the residence…It appears that the injury was caused by AP’s deliberate act in dropping to the ground while her arm was restrained.”


Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter


Just Posted

An air ambulance leaves West Coast General Hospital for a trauma centre at 9:50 p.m. on Wednesday, June 12 after a Port Alberni youth was injured in an accident on the Somass River. SUSAN QUINN PHOTO
COVID-19 outbreaks at pair of Vancouver Island Hospitals

Saanich Peninsula Hospital in Saanichton and West Coast General Hospital in Port Alberni affected

Pamela Evans gazes lovingly at her four-year-old French bulldog Jack on Thursday, Nov. 5. The energetic young pup has regained his usual rambunctiousness after recently recovering from a significant illness brought on by consuming discarded cannabis new Brown’s Beach in Ucluelet. (Andrew Bailey photo)
Discarded cannabis a “frequent” threat to pets in Tofino-Ucluelet

“I couldn’t grab him fast enough to get it out of his mouth before he swallowed it.”

Steven Michael Bacon, is expected to see his next court date Feb. 12, in B.C. provincial court in Nanaimo, where a date for a preliminary inquiry could be set. (News Bulletin file)
Date for preliminary inquiry in Makayla Chang murder case expected in two months’ time

Steven Michael Bacon’s next appearance in Nanaimo court set for Feb. 12

Beautiful morning with the sun peaking through, as viewed from Thetis Island. (Photo by Kelly Bannister)
November characterized by no snow, plenty of rain and a record high for one Island town

Temperature almost hits the 20 degree Celsius mark in Chemainus on Nov. 4

Harrop: How will we describe pandemic life in years to come?

Comparisons to World War II come close, but there are significant differences between then and now.

A tongue-in-cheek message about wearing a face mask to curb the spread of COVID-19 on a sign outside a church near Royal Columbia Hospital, in New Westminster, B.C., on Sunday, Nov. 29, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
B.C.’s COVID-19 infection count climbs back up to 656

20 more people in hospital, active cases still rising

A man stands in the window of an upper floor condo in Vancouver on March 24, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck
Change made to insurance for B.C. condo owners amid rising premiums

Council CEO Janet Sinclair says the change will mean less price volatility

Sidney’s Haunted Bookshop is changing owners with longtime owner Odean Long transferring ownership Dec. 1 to William Matthews. (Wolf Depner/News Staff)
Longtime owner of Sidney’s Haunted Bookshop closes chapter with sale

Odean Long and her late husband moved the business to Sidney in 1996

Local poet and VIU professor Sonnet L’Abbé wrote and performed a song as part of the city’s Reimagine Nanaimo campaign. (Photo courtesy City of Nanaimo/Port Theatre)
Poet pens song as part of city’s Reimagine Nanaimo campaign

Sonnet L’Abbé encourages a friend to move to the city in ‘Nazaneen: A Song for Nanaimo’

Teagan Hunt (Grade 12) and Aiden Grew (Grade 11) are the 2020 winners of Lambrick Park’s annual Queen & King of the Hill demanding race up Mount Doug’s Churchill Drive. (Photo courtesy of Tom Turnbull)
Lambrick King of the Hill wins Cedar Hill time trial

Aiden Grew sets course record for gruelling King of the Hill run

Stephen Laidlaw, prepator with Nanaimo Art Gallery, hangs a photograph of Anna Wong, a B.C. print maker whose works are on display at the gallery. The exhibit opens Friday, Dec. 4, and runs until Feb. 7. (Chris Bush/News Bulletin)
Nanaimo Art Gallery exhibit explores life work of overlooked B.C. printmaker

‘Anna Wong: Traveller on Two Roads’ features more than 70 art works and personal belongings

Dave Wallace coached the Parksville Royals for 23 years. (PQB News file photo)
B.C. baseball community mourns death of legendary Vancouver Island coach Dave Wallace

‘All who knew Dave and his passion for the game will miss him greatly’

Most Read